Could Nuns, Convents Benefit from Home Health Care?
Nuns living in a convent in upstate New York were recently forced to leave their home and enter nearby assisted living communities for fear they would not be able to adequately take care of themselves and each other as they aged, says the New York Times’ latest The New Old Age blog post, but the move could have been avoidable had the sisters been able to work out a deal with a senior care provider or home health care agency.
As fewer young women join the ranks of Roman Catholic nuns, convents are effectively becoming “old age homes”—only without the services found in residential care homes, says the blog post.
There [were] years of deliberation and consultation in the decision to disperse this local order of the Sisters of Saint Francis of the Neumann Communities to nearby facilities for the elderly. For that the nuns are grateful. But they are not unmarked by the disruption.
As far back as 2004, with their ranks aging and virtually no infusion of young women into the religious life, the Hastings congregation merged with other Sisters of Saint Francis congregations from Syracuse and Williamsville, in upstate New York. They hoped to pool their resources to care for a wave of aged and increasingly infirm nuns.
While their combined numbers increased as a result of the mergers, Sister Salerno explained, the congregation’s costs remained unsustainably high.
“Our main mission is service,’’ she said, “and we can’t discourage the possibility of newcomers by letting them think if they join us, it will mean coming to take care of a lot of old ladies.’’
Effectively, convents were becoming old-age homes, but with inadequate infrastructure and volunteer staff.
“Could we build?’’ Sister Salerno mused. “Could we go into partnership with other providers, where they owned and we rented?”
Instead, while the convent held neighborhood “tag sales,” selling or giving away the detritus accumulated over more than 50 years, placements were found for the sisters at two nearby facilities. They got to choose which they’d like to move to. More than 25 went to the Wartburg Adult Care Community in Mt. Vernon, run by the Lutheran Church. It offers many levels of care, including independent living cottages, an assisted living building, a memory care unit and a skilled nursing home.
For some of the nuns, choosing a community offering a full continuum of care was highly intentional, as they wanted the move to be their last, notes the article.
Read the full piece at the New York Times.
Written by Alyssa Gerace